Are you planning to buy a MacBook but not sure which one to choose – the thin and light Air or the more powerful Pro? There are significant differences in performance, battery life, and screen technology between current models that can affect your long-term satisfaction with the device. Let’s take a closer look at what factors should guide your decision.
MacBook Air vs Pro: Key Differences
The MacBook world divides into two main directions: Air represents lightness and mobility, while the Pro series focuses on top performance and professional features.
Key differences:
- Design: Air is thinner and wedge-shaped (newer models have more uniform thickness), Pro is slightly thicker
- Cooling: Air is fanless (silent), Pro uses active cooling (audible during intensive tasks)
- Weight: Air weighs 1.24-1.51 kg, Pro weighs 1.4-2.15 kg (depending on model)
- Performance: Air is ideal for regular work, Pro offers more sustained performance for intensive tasks
- Display: Air uses standard Liquid Retina, Pro offers XDR technology and 120Hz refresh rate
- Connectivity: Pro offers more ports (HDMI, SD card slot)
Performance and Speed: Is the Difference Noticeable?
Apple’s M-series chips have fundamentally changed MacBook performance capabilities compared to earlier Intel-based Macs, but there are also significant differences between M-chips.
Processors and Real-world Experience
MacBook Air uses base M-chips (M1, M2, M3, M4), while Pro models offer Pro, Max, and Ultra variants with additional cores and graphical performance.
Tests show that the MacBook Air M4 is about 10% faster than the previous M3 model. In GPU tests, M2, M3, and M4 are relatively similar in basic calculations, but M3 is 25% faster than M2 in Blender animation rendering, and M4 is 10% faster than M3.
Blackmagic disk write speed tests (MBps):
- MacBook Air M1: 2904
- MacBook Air M2: 2800
- MacBook Air M3: 2981
- MacBook Pro M3 Pro: 4211
- MacBook Pro M4 Pro: 6640
Thermal Performance and Cooling
The most critical difference lies in thermal behavior:
- MacBook Air: All M1-M4 Air models heat up similarly under intensive load. The lack of a fan means that under prolonged load, the processor may slow down to avoid overheating.
- MacBook Pro: With active cooling, performance remains more stable even during longer intensive tasks.
If you do short-term demanding activities or primarily everyday work, the MacBook Air is sufficient. For regular intensive tasks, consider a Pro model.
Battery Life and Mobility
Battery is crucial for mobile work, and M-series models have made a big leap here.
Practical Battery Tests
Comparative test where all models were used for the same tasks until M1 reached 5%:
- M2 was at 16-18% battery level at that point
- M3 was at 19-21% battery level
In real-world use, M3 and M4 offer about 10 hours of work time, M2 slightly over 8 hours. Notably, even a 4-year-old M1’s maximum capacity reduction is around 90%, which is an excellent result.
Portability and Weight
MacBook Air truly lives up to its name:
- MacBook Air 13″: about 1.24-1.29 kg
- MacBook Air 15″: about 1.51 kg
- MacBook Pro 14″: 1.55-1.61 kg
- MacBook Pro 16″: 2.14-2.16 kg
This weight difference becomes particularly noticeable when carrying it daily.
Displays: Is the Pro Advantage Noticeable?
The display is one of the clearest differences between Air and Pro:
MacBook Air Displays
- 13.6″ or 15.3″ Liquid Retina IPS display
- 500 nits brightness
- P3 color space
- 60Hz refresh rate
MacBook Pro Displays
- 14.2″ or 16.2″ Liquid Retina XDR (mini-LED)
- 1000 nits sustained brightness (1600 nits peak brightness with HDR content)
- P3 color space
- ProMotion (up to 120Hz adaptive refresh rate)
The Pro’s higher contrast, brightness, and smoother motion are clearly visible in photo and video editing, but ProMotion also provides a noticeably smoother experience in regular use.
Ports and Connectivity
The difference in ports can mean less need for adapters:
MacBook Air (M2/M3/M4)
- 2 × Thunderbolt / USB 4 ports
- MagSafe 3 charging port
- 3.5 mm headphone jack
MacBook Pro (newer models)
- 3 × Thunderbolt / USB 4 ports
- HDMI port
- SDXC card reader
- MagSafe 3 charging port
- 3.5 mm headphone jack
Note: M1 Air and earlier models have only 2 USB-C ports without MagSafe.
If you regularly work with external devices, especially camera memory cards, the Pro’s port selection can significantly simplify your work. Alternatively, you can add a quality USB-C adapter to Air models to expand connectivity options.
Price and Value
The price difference between Air and Pro is significant:
Refurbished Models (UPGREAT prices)
- MacBook Air 2020 (M1) from €449
- MacBook Air 2024 (M3/M4) from €1119
- MacBook Pro 2019 (Intel) from €339
- MacBook Pro 2021 (M1 Pro/Max) from €839
- MacBook Pro 2022 (M2 Pro/Max) from €909
- MacBook Pro 2023 (M3 Pro/Max) from €1269
A refurbished MacBook can be a great way to get more power at a lower price. All UPGREAT refurbished MacBooks are thoroughly checked and come with a 2-year warranty.
Which MacBook Fits Your Needs?
MacBook Air is the Right Choice If:
- You need a light and thin computer for daily carrying
- You mainly do web browsing, documents, spreadsheets, presentations
- You have a limited budget
- You value a quiet (fanless) work environment
MacBook Pro is Worth Choosing If:
- You regularly process video, photos, or 3D graphics
- You develop software, compile code, or use virtual machines
- You need a professional display with accurate color reproduction and high brightness
- You use many external devices and memory cards
Recommendations for Different Use Cases
Study and Office Use
For students and office workers, as mentioned in this overview, the MacBook Air is perfectly suitable. M1 or M2 based models offer exceptional value for money.
Photo and Video Editing
For creative professionals, we recommend a MacBook Pro model with at least 16GB of memory to ensure smooth work with large files.
Programming and Development
Developers often need more memory and cores, especially for large projects and virtual machines.
Professional 3D/Video/Audio Processing
For the most demanding users, MacBook Pro models with M3 Pro or Max chips are suitable.
Summary
MacBook Air offers the ideal balance of performance, portability, and price for most users. If your work doesn’t require constant maximum performance, Air is the logical choice.
MacBook Pro is a real investment for those doing intensive work, offering significant advantages in screen, cooling, and ports. Before buying a Pro, ask yourself if you really use these advantages regularly enough to justify the price difference.
Regardless of your choice, consider buying a refurbished MacBook – you get the same quality at the lowest price and support more environmentally friendly technology use.
Also check out our blog, where we share reviews of trends and news.
To stay updated with Upgreat promotions, add us as a friend on FB or follow us on Instagram.
